A little shoulder anatomy: the humeral head is the upper end of the humerus, comprising a cartilaginous part that articulates with the scapula, and another part — the tuberosities — to which the rotator cuff tendons attach, tendons essential for shoulder function. The glenoid is the name given to the articular surface of the scapula; it articulates with the cartilaginous part of the humeral head, forming the glenohumeral joint.

A total shoulder replacement replaces the articular surfaces of the glenohumeral joint. The prosthesis thus replaces both articular surfaces: the glenoid and the cartilaginous surface of the humeral head.

Which type of shoulder replacement?

There are two very different types of total shoulder replacement: the anatomical total shoulder replacement, and the reverse total shoulder replacement. The anatomical shoulder replacement reproduces the anatomy of the shoulder: on the humeral side, there is a hemisphere equivalent to the humeral head being replaced; on the scapular side, a small cup equivalent to the glenoid surface. The reverse shoulder replacement, as the name suggests, inverts the articular surfaces: the hemisphere is fixed to the scapula and the cup to the humerus.

The choice between an anatomical shoulder replacement and a reverse shoulder replacement depends primarily on the condition of the tendons attached to the humeral head, i.e. the rotator cuff. If the rotator cuff tendons are damaged, an anatomical shoulder replacement cannot function correctly. There are also other situations where a reverse shoulder replacement is preferable to an anatomical one, particularly when taking into account glenoid wear or poor centring of the humeral head against the glenoid.

130 PubMed-indexed publications

Why do I need an anatomical or reverse shoulder replacement?

A little anatomy

The humeral head is the upper end of the humerus, comprising a cartilaginous part that articulates with the scapula, and another part — the tuberosities — to which the rotator cuff tendons attach. The glenoid is the articular surface of the scapula; it articulates with the cartilaginous part of the humeral head, forming the glenohumeral joint.

A total shoulder replacement replaces both articular surfaces of the glenohumeral joint: the glenoid and the cartilaginous surface of the humeral head.

‍

Which type of shoulder replacement?

There are two very different types of total shoulder replacement: the anatomical total shoulder replacement and the reverse total shoulder replacement.

The anatomical total shoulder replacement reproduces shoulder anatomy: on the humeral side, a hemisphere equivalent to the humeral head being replaced; on the scapular side, a small cup equivalent to the glenoid surface. A French innovation almost 30 years old, the reverse total shoulder replacement, as the name suggests, inverts the articular surfaces: the hemisphere is fixed to the scapula and the cup to the humerus. The choice between anatomical and reverse shoulder replacement depends primarily on the condition of the rotator cuff tendons. If the rotator cuff tendons are damaged, an anatomical shoulder replacement cannot function correctly. There are however other situations where a reverse total shoulder replacement is preferable

to an anatomical total shoulder replacement, particularly taking into account glenoid wear or poor centring of the humeral head against the glenoid.

The reverse total shoulder replacement

The reverse total shoulder replacement is most often (though not always) required to treat osteoarthritis. Osteoarthritis is defined as the mirror-wear of all or part of the articular cartilage covering the humeral head and the glenoid. The slow, progressive and inexorable wear of cartilage can be compared to the wear of a car tyre. It is excessive loading or abnormal orientation of the articular surfaces that explains this wear.

This is the point at which a total shoulder replacement is required. To continue the car analogy: replacing the worn tyre with a new one is the solution, as everyone knows you cannot drive for long on the rim!

Note: other factors can promote the development of osteoarthritis, such as genetic factors which remain unexplained to date, traumatic factors (post-fracture or post-instability sequelae), but also certain inflammatory diseases (rheumatoid arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis), or others such as a blood disease, aseptic necrosis, a metabolic disorder such as gout, or chondrocalcinosis.

The reverse replacement is also sometimes proposed when there is no osteoarthritis, but simply a significant or long-standing rotator cuff tear.

‍

Physiotherapy 2 to 3 times a week if possible.

Self-rehabilitation: exercises 1, 2 & 3 to be done 5 times a day (1 minute per exercise).

Use of the operated arm permitted for simple daily activities such as dressing, eating, washing.

Carrying loads and strength activities are strictly FORBIDDEN.

At the end of the 6 weeks, you will have your first post-operative review with a follow-up X-ray.

Physiotherapy 1 to 2 times a week if possible.

Self-rehabilitation: start exercise 4, then gradually exercises 5 and 6.

Use of the operated arm permitted for simple daily activities. Nothing physical, no lifting.

Resuming driving.

At the end of the third month, you will have your second post-operative review with a follow-up X-ray.

Authorisation to do housework, swimming, cycling...

More physical activities, DIY, gardening...

‍

‍

The anatomical total shoulder replacement

Why do I need an anatomical total shoulder replacement?

The anatomical total shoulder replacement is most often required to treat osteoarthritis. Osteoarthritis is defined as the mirror-wear of all or part of the articular cartilage covering the humeral head and the glenoid. The slow, progressive and inexorable wear of cartilage can be compared to the wear of a car tyre. It is excessive loading or abnormal orientation of the articular surfaces that explains this wear. This is the point at which a total shoulder replacement is required. To continue the car analogy: replacing the worn tyre with a new one is the solution, as everyone knows you cannot drive for long on the rim!

Note: other factors can promote the development of osteoarthritis such as genetic factors which remain unexplained to date, traumatic factors (post-fracture or post-instability sequelae), but also certain inflammatory diseases (rheumatoid arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis), or others such as a blood disease, aseptic necrosis, a metabolic disorder such as gout, or chondrocalcinosis.

Physiotherapy 3 times a week if possible.

Self-rehabilitation: exercises 1 & 2 to be done 5 times a day (1 minute per exercise).

Wear a sling day and night (except at rest during the day and during dressing, washing,

meals, physiotherapy sessions and self-rehabilitation exercises).

Use of the operated arm permitted for simple daily activities

such as dressing, eating, washing (without the hand being above the head).

Carrying loads and strength activities are strictly FORBIDDEN.

Physiotherapy 3 times a week if possible.

Self-rehabilitation: exercises 1, 2 & 3 to be done 5 times a day (1 minute per exercise).

Gradually remove the sling: first during the day at home, then during outdoor

activities, and finally at night.

Use of the operated arm permitted for simple daily activities

such as dressing, eating, washing (without the hand being above the head).

Carrying loads and strength activities are strictly FORBIDDEN.

Physiotherapy 3 times a week if possible. Self-rehabilitation: start exercise 4, then gradually exercises 5 and 6 according to your progress.

No more sling.

Use of the operated arm permitted for simple daily activities BUT nothing heavy, nothing repetitive, no housework, no washing-up.

Resuming driving.

No prolonged or excessive walking.

At the end of the 3rd month, you will have your second post-operative review.

Physiotherapy 2 times then once a week.

All self-rehabilitation exercises adding exercise 7.

Authorisation to gradually resume housework, road or indoor cycling,

swimming, jogging or brisk walking.

At the end of the 6th month, you will have your third post-operative review.

Physical activity, lifting, DIY, gardening...

Need more information?

Contact Dr. Collin

Questions fréquentes

Quelle est la différence entre prothèse d'épaule anatomique et inversée ?
La prothèse anatomique reproduit l'anatomie : une sphère côté humérus, une cupule côté omoplate. La prothèse inversée inverse ces surfaces (sphère sur l'omoplate, cupule sur l'humérus). Le choix dépend essentiellement de l'état des tendons de la coiffe des rotateurs.
Quand une prothèse d'épaule devient-elle nécessaire ?
Le plus souvent pour traiter une arthrose, c'est-à-dire l'usure du cartilage de l'articulation. Elle peut aussi être indiquée en cas de rupture massive ou ancienne de la coiffe des rotateurs. On l'envisage quand la douleur et la gêne deviennent invalidantes.
Comment choisit-on entre les deux types de prothèse ?
Selon l'état des tendons : si la coiffe des rotateurs est abîmée, une prothèse anatomique ne peut pas fonctionner correctement et l'on privilégie l'inversée. L'usure de la glène et le défaut de centrage de la tête humérale entrent aussi en compte.
Quelle est la récupération après une prothèse d'épaule ?
Port d'une attelle entre 4 et 6 semaines selon les patients, avec interdiction de porter des charges. La conduite reprend entre 1,5 et 3 mois selon les patients, le ménage, le vélo et la natation vers 3 mois, puis les activités physiques vers 6 mois. Des bilans radiographiques sont réalisés à 6 semaines, 3 mois et 6 mois.
Combien de temps dure une prothèse d'épaule ?
Une prothèse d'épaule moderne fonctionne généralement plus de 15 ans. Sa longévité dépend du type d'implant, de la qualité osseuse et du niveau d'activité. Un suivi régulier permet de surveiller son bon état dans le temps.
La pose de prothèse bénéficie-t-elle des nouvelles technologies ?
Oui. Le Dr Collin intègre la planification 3D personnalisée et la réalité mixte (augmentée) au bloc opératoire pour améliorer la précision de positionnement de l'implant, gage de fiabilité et de longévité de la reconstruction.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an anatomic and a reverse shoulder replacement?
The anatomic prosthesis reproduces the natural anatomy: a sphere on the humeral side, a cup on the scapular side. The reverse prosthesis swaps these surfaces (sphere on the scapula, cup on the humerus). The choice depends essentially on the condition of the rotator cuff tendons.
When does a shoulder replacement become necessary?
Most often to treat osteoarthritis, i.e. wear of the joint cartilage. It may also be indicated for a massive or long-standing rotator cuff tear. It is considered when pain and loss of function become disabling.
How is the type of prosthesis chosen?
According to the state of the tendons: if the rotator cuff is damaged, an anatomic prosthesis cannot work properly and the reverse is preferred. Glenoid wear and poor centring of the humeral head also play a part.
What is recovery like after a shoulder replacement?
A sling for between 4 and 6 weeks depending on the patient, with no load-bearing. Driving resumes between 1.5 and 3 months depending on the patient, housework, cycling and swimming at around 3 months, then physical activities at around 6 months. X-ray check-ups are carried out at 6 weeks, 3 months and 6 months.
How long does a shoulder replacement last?
A modern shoulder prosthesis generally lasts more than 15 years. Its longevity depends on the implant type, bone quality and activity level. Regular follow-up monitors its condition over time.
Does the procedure benefit from new technologies?
Yes. Dr Collin uses personalised 3D planning and mixed (augmented) reality in the operating room to improve the accuracy of implant positioning, a guarantee of reliability and longevity for the reconstruction.

الأسئلة الشائعة

ما الفرق بين المفصل الاصطناعي التشريحي والمفصل الاصطناعي المعكوس للكتف؟
يحاكي المفصل الاصطناعي التشريحي البنية الطبيعية للكتف: جزء كروي في جهة عظم العضد، وتجويف صغير في جهة لوح الكتف. أما المفصل الاصطناعي المعكوس فيعكس هذين السطحين (الجزء الكروي على لوح الكتف، والتجويف على عظم العضد). ويعتمد الاختيار أساسًا على حالة أوتار الكفة المدورة.
متى يصبح تركيب مفصل اصطناعي للكتف ضروريًا؟
في أغلب الأحيان لعلاج خشونة المفصل (الفُصال العظمي)، أي تآكل غضروف المفصل. وقد يُنصح به أيضًا في حالة تمزق واسع أو قديم في الكفة المدورة. ويُلجأ إليه عندما يصبح الألم وصعوبة استخدام الكتف مُعيقَين في الحياة اليومية.
كيف يتم الاختيار بين نوعي المفصل الاصطناعي؟
حسب حالة الأوتار: إذا كانت الكفة المدورة متضررة، فلا يمكن للمفصل الاصطناعي التشريحي أن يعمل بشكل سليم، ويُفضَّل عندها المفصل المعكوس. كما يؤخذ في الاعتبار تآكل الحُقّة (السطح المفصلي للوح الكتف) وعدم تمركز رأس عظم العضد في مواجهتها.
كيف تكون فترة التعافي بعد تركيب مفصل اصطناعي للكتف؟
ارتداء حمّالة الذراع لمدة تتراوح بين 4 و6 أسابيع حسب كل مريض، مع منع حمل الأثقال. وتُستأنف قيادة السيارة بعد مدة تتراوح بين شهر ونصف و3 أشهر حسب كل مريض، والأعمال المنزلية وركوب الدراجة والسباحة بعد نحو 3 أشهر، ثم الأنشطة البدنية بعد نحو 6 أشهر. وتُجرى فحوص بالأشعة بعد 6 أسابيع و3 أشهر و6 أشهر.
كم يدوم المفصل الاصطناعي للكتف؟
يعمل المفصل الاصطناعي الحديث للكتف عادةً لأكثر من 15 عامًا. وتعتمد مدة بقائه على نوع الغرسة وجودة العظم ومستوى النشاط. وتتيح المتابعة المنتظمة مراقبة حالته مع مرور الوقت.
هل تستفيد عملية تركيب المفصل الاصطناعي من التقنيات الحديثة؟
نعم. يستخدم الدكتور كولان التخطيط ثلاثي الأبعاد المخصص لكل مريض والواقع المختلط (المعزز) في غرفة العمليات لتحسين دقة وضع الغرسة، مما يضمن موثوقية الترميم وطول عمره.

Perguntas frequentes

Qual é a diferença entre a prótese de ombro anatômica e a reversa?
A prótese anatômica reproduz a anatomia: uma esfera do lado do úmero e uma pequena cúpula do lado da escápula. A prótese reversa inverte essas superfícies (esfera na escápula, cúpula no úmero). A escolha depende essencialmente do estado dos tendões do manguito rotador.
Quando a prótese de ombro se torna necessária?
Na maioria das vezes, para tratar a artrose, ou seja, o desgaste da cartilagem da articulação. Ela também pode ser indicada em caso de ruptura extensa ou antiga do manguito rotador. É considerada quando a dor e a limitação se tornam incapacitantes.
Como se escolhe entre os dois tipos de prótese?
De acordo com o estado dos tendões: se o manguito rotador estiver lesionado, a prótese anatômica não consegue funcionar corretamente e a reversa é a preferida. O desgaste da glenoide e a falta de centralização da cabeça do úmero também são levados em conta.
Como é a recuperação após uma prótese de ombro?
Uso de tipoia entre 4 e 6 semanas, conforme o paciente, sem carregar peso. A volta a dirigir acontece entre 1 mês e meio e 3 meses, conforme o paciente; as tarefas domésticas, a bicicleta e a natação, por volta de 3 meses; e as atividades físicas, por volta de 6 meses. Avaliações com radiografia são realizadas com 6 semanas, 3 meses e 6 meses.
Quanto tempo dura uma prótese de ombro?
Uma prótese de ombro moderna geralmente funciona por mais de 15 anos. Sua durabilidade depende do tipo de implante, da qualidade óssea e do nível de atividade. O acompanhamento regular permite monitorar o seu bom estado ao longo do tempo.
A colocação da prótese se beneficia das novas tecnologias?
Sim. O Dr. Collin utiliza o planejamento 3D personalizado e a realidade mista (aumentada) no centro cirúrgico para aumentar a precisão do posicionamento do implante, garantia de confiabilidade e de durabilidade da reconstrução.