A tear of the rotator cuff does not, in itself, call for surgery. Plenty of tears are found by chance in patients whose shoulder does not hurt at all, and I never operate on an image. What I treat is pain that resists, strength that is missing, a shoulder that no longer does its job. Two facts are essential: one person in three over the age of 60 has a rotator cuff tear, and as long as 3 of the 5 tendons remain, we can live normally.
I offer a repair when the pain persists despite several months of medical treatment and well conducted physiotherapy, when the loss of strength gets in the way of everyday life or of your work, and when the imaging shows a tendon that is still repairable.
There are also situations where I suggest operating sooner, without waiting for medical treatment to fail: a recent traumatic tear in an active patient, a tear that grows from one scan to the next, or a subscapularis tear, which repairs badly once it has been left to age.
The factor that really decides is the state of the muscle on the MRI or the CT arthrogram, far more than the size of the tear or the age on your passport. A muscle that has turned to fat will not get its strength back even if the tendon is reattached. That degeneration is not reversible, and it is the real reason not to wait years before seeing a shoulder surgeon.
The repair is done arthroscopically, that is through small incisions of less than a centimetre, through which I pass a camera and the instruments. There is no large scar and the muscles are not opened.
I operate under regional anaesthesia: you are not asleep during the operation unless you would like to be.
I start by exploring the joint, because arthroscopy shows things imaging does not: the true state of the tendon and of the long head of biceps. I then free the retracted tendon so that it can be brought back to its footprint on the bone without tension, I refresh the bone surface, then I fix the tendon with anchors. The tendon is not stitched to another tendon, it is pressed back against the bone, onto which it has to heal.
Depending on what I find, I often add other steps in the same operation: treating the long head of biceps when it is inflamed or dislocated, an acromioplasty when the acromion is attacking the tendon, or treating an associated calcification. These steps do not lengthen the recovery.
You go home the same day or the next morning. You leave with a prescription for painkillers and a written rehabilitation protocol, with exercises dated week by week. All our exercises are explained on Dr Philippe Collin's YouTube channel.
A rotator cuff repair is sometimes more painful in the first few days than a shoulder replacement. The tendon has just been put back under tension on the bone. We pay very close attention to your pain after the operation. A precise record of your pain over the first 3 days is sent to us, so that we can adapt to each patient. It also lets us adjust our protocol regularly to keep improving it. Overall, pain is rated at 3/10 on the first day, 2/10 on the second day and 1/10, or even 0, from the third day onwards.
The first three or four days are the hardest, with pain that is often worse at night, well covered by the "nerve block", after which painkillers take over. Icing regularly and sleeping half sitting up make a real difference during this period.
Between the second and the sixth week, the background pain drops clearly. After that, many patients still have end of day soreness and intermittent night waking for two to three months. This is normal and it does not mean the repair has failed.
Pain that increases instead of easing, a fever, redness or any discharge are not normal after surgery, and you should call me straight away.
This is the essential difference with a shoulder replacement. When I implant a prosthesis, I detach no muscle, so there is nothing to protect and no immobilisation. When I repair a rotator cuff, a tendon has been "pressed back" onto the bone and has to heal there.
During that time, the tendon must not work actively against resistance. You use your arm for simple things, getting dressed, eating, washing, but you do not lift, you do not pull, and you do not push up on it. This is the one moment in the whole journey where patience matters more than willpower.
It is progressive and it follows a written timetable, in a booklet that I hand you when you leave hospital. The self-rehabilitation exercises build on one another week after week, around the fourth to the sixth week, then the fifth to the eighth, then the sixth to the tenth, then the seventh to the twelfth week after the operation.
Physiotherapy starts with passive mobilisation, to keep the shoulder supple without stressing the repair. Active movement comes next, and strengthening comes last, once the tendon has healed.
Movement generally comes back before strength. It is common to have a supple shoulder at three months and to keep gaining strength up to a year. The result is therefore judged over time, and I never pass judgement on a rotator cuff repair before six months.
Driving starts again when you can hold the wheel with both hands and manoeuvre without pain or apprehension, which depends a great deal on which side was operated and on your car.
Going back to work depends entirely on the job. A desk job resumes far sooner than heavy work or a trade that means working with your arms above shoulder height. We set that date together in consultation, based on the movements you actually make, and I will support you with occupational health if your role needs adjusting.
As for sport, swimming, racket sports and weight training come last, once healing is complete and strength has returned.
The risk specific to this surgery is not infection, which is exceptional in arthroscopy, but healing. The tendon may not take on the bone, which is what we call a re-tear or a failure to heal.
The size of the tear, the state of the muscle before surgery, age and smoking are the main factors affecting your recovery. Smoking is the only one you can act on, and that is why I always ask patients to stop before the operation.
One reassuring point: a re-tear does not mean a functional failure. Many patients whose tendon has not healed perfectly keep a pain-free, usable shoulder, because releasing the tendon, treating the biceps and physiotherapy have changed the balance of the shoulder. I have published extensively on this in the scientific literature.
The other risks are those of any shoulder surgery: post operative stiffness, more frequent here than after a shoulder replacement, temporary nerve irritation, haematoma. I go through them one by one with you in consultation.
Sometimes the tendon is too retracted or the muscle too degenerated to hope for healing. That is not a dead end. Depending on your age, your functional demands and the state of the joint, we then discuss a non prosthetic treatment, a tendon transfer, or a reverse shoulder replacement, which gives back the ability to lift the arm without needing the tendons.
It is a decision that is taken by two, after looking at the images together and talking about what you expect from your shoulder.
The operation is done arthroscopically and generally takes around 30 minutes, longer if the tear is extensive or if several procedures are combined. You go home the same day.
Not necessarily. A tear does not by itself require surgery: we operate on pain that resists or strength that is missing, not on an image. That said, a torn tendon never reattaches on its own and the muscle degenerates over time, which can close the door on a repair if you wait too long.
The first three or four days are the most painful, then the background pain drops clearly between the second and the sixth week. End of day soreness and intermittent night waking can persist for two to three months without being a cause for concern.
Rehabilitation follows a written timetable over about three months, with exercises added week after week and strengthening later on. Movement often comes back around three months, while strength keeps improving up to a year.
Yes, that is the risk specific to this surgery. It depends on the size of the tear, the state of the muscle before surgery, age and smoking. A retear does not mean failure: many patients keep a pain free, usable shoulder.
It clearly slows healing down. Smoking impoverishes the blood supply to the tendon and reduces the chance that it takes on the bone. It is the only risk factor a patient can act on.
It is not a dead end. Depending on your age, your functional demands and the state of the joint, we discuss a non prosthetic treatment, a tendon transfer or a reverse shoulder replacement, which gives back the ability to lift the arm without needing the tendons.